NH INSIDER

Oppose FDA Declaration of Electroshock Safety
Deadline is THIS FRIDAY, January 8, 2010

The FDA Wants to Declare Electroshock Machines
Safe Without a Safety Investigation. 
TELL THEM NO!

The Food and Drug Administration is in charge of regulating medical devices just as it does drugs, including the machines used to give Electroshock. But it's not doing its job. It has allowed these machines to be used on millions of patients over the past generation without requiring any evidence whatsoever that shock treatment is safe or effective. This is so even though shock machines are Class III -- high risk -- devices, which by law are required to be subjected to thorough clinical trials as thoroughly as new drugs and devices just coming onto the market. But because of intense lobbying by the American Psychiatric Association -- which claims the devices are safe but opposes an investigation -- the FDA has disregarded its own law. (For the full story of how shock survivors and other advocates have fought for a scientific safety investigation of Electroshock for the past 25 years, see Linda Andre's new book, Doctors of Deception: What They Don't Want You to Know About Shock Treatment.)

In April 2009 -- 30 years after it first ruled the devices high-risk and named brain damage and memory loss as risks of the treatment -- the FDA belatedly announced it would call on the manufacturers of the devices to provide evidence of safety and efficacy. The deadline for submissions has passed, but the manufacturers have not conducted any clinical trials, claiming they cannot afford them. They simply point to the opinions of shock doctors (including those who have financial interests in companies making Electroshock machines) as evidence that shock is safe.

 [To submit your electronic comment to the FDA, click here.]

For more information and sample letters, please visit our website: http://www.ncmhcso.org/ect.htm 

National Coalition of Mental Health ConsumerSurvivor Organizations

The FDA Wants to Declare Electroshock Machines Safe Without a Safety  Investigation.
TELL THEM NO! 

The Food and Drug Administration is in charge of regulating medical devices just as it does drugs, including the machines used to give Electroshock. But it's not doing its job.  It has allowed these machines to be used on millions of patients over the past generation without requiring any evidence whatsoever that shock treatment is safe or effective! This is so even though shock machines are Class III---high risk---devices, which by law are supposed to be investigated by clinical trials as thoroughly as new drugs and devices just coming onto the market. But because of intense lobbying by the American Psychiatric Association---which claims the devices are safe but opposes an investigation---the FDA has disregarded its own law.  (For the full story of how shock survivors have  fought for a scientific safety investigation of  Electroshock for the past 25 years, see Linda Andre's terrific new book, Doctors of Deception: What They Don't Want You to Know About Shock Treatment.)  

      In April 2009---20 years after it first ruled the devices high-risk and named brain damage and memory loss as risks of the treatment---the FDA belatedly announced it would call on the manufacturers of the devices to provide evidence of safety and efficacy. The deadline for submissions has passed, but the manufacturers have not conducted any clinical trials, claiming they cannot afford them. They simply point to the opinions of shock doctors (including those who  have financial interests in companies making Electroshock machines) as evidence that shock is safe.

      The FDA is now supposed to require Electroshock machines to undergo the rigorous PreMarket Approval process (PMA) that is required of new devices, including clinical safety trials.  These machines, technically known as "devices," are referred to as  Electro Convulsive Therapy (ECT), but I don't like to use this euphemistic term for running electricity through people's brains.  The FDA  could have called for this investigation any time in the past 30 years but has previously failed to do so.  There is great risk the FDA will downclassify it to the low-risk Class II, without  scientific evidence of  its safety. As a Class II  device, Electroshock machines would never have to go through the PMA process.  The amount of damage that electroshock has been allowed to inflict is an outrage.  We now finally have a chance to at least register our opposition because the FDA has opened  up a new docket for public comment on electroshock machines.  It is important for as many people as possible to write in with their opposition.  Comments will be accepted up through January 2010.  

    If you have personal knowledge or expertise about Electroshock, writing about that can be good.  Or you can pull information from various sources.  Linda Andre's book, Doctors of Deception is a gold mine of information.  Leonard Roy Frank issued the Electroshock Quotationary, in June 2006, which is a good source of material, and there is also a brand new web page of historical materials from Leonard at http://psychiatrized.org/LeonardRoyFrank/FromTheFilesOfLeonardRoyFrank.htm   Also, PsychRights has quite a large collection of materials at http://psychrights.org/Research/Digest/Electroshock/electroshock.htm from which comments can be drawn. 

If you are not in a position to write something up, then please send in the below coupon. 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
To: Food and Drug Administration, Dockets Management Branch (HFA-305), 5630 Fishers Lane, Room 1061, Rockville, MD 20852

Re: Electroconvulsive Therapy Device (882.5940), Docket #FDA-2009-N0392

The undersigned opposes the reclassification of the ECT device to Class II by the FDA in the absence of adequate scientific evidence of its safety, and asks the agency to call for PreMarket Approval Applications for the device.

Name:     ___________________________
Address: _________________________          
                 _________________________
Signature: _________________________

Tobacco Prohibition?: Last week, another bill was passed and signed into law that takes more of our freedoms and violates the Constitution of the United States. It was, of course, done for the sake of the children, and in the name of the health of the citizenry. It's always the case that when your liberty is seized, it is seized for your own good. Such is the condescension of Washington.

Unemployment: Who is really to blame?:As soon as newly elected Democratic majority took over Congress in 2007, they aimed their scope at setting a new minimum wage. Unfortunately, while the Senators and Representatives were patting each other on the backs for passing the first bill that raised the minimum wage in nearly a decade, they forgot to consult any economics textbook.

ABC - All Barack Channel: On June 24, Drudge reports, the network will broadcast from inside the White House to air a propaganda special for Obamacare.

Seeing Through the Rhetoric: Having relied on vague intangibles during the campaign, Barack Obama—staying true to form—is back to the same-old, same-old.

Be sure to follow us on Twitter!

Audit the Fed Update: Over the past week, a number of new signers have joined in the efforts of supporting H.R. 1207, the Audit the Fed bill sponsored by Ron Paul. The total number of cosponsors that are now on the bill has surpassed a majority of the members of congress and currently has 223 co-sponsors!

Keep FDA Away From Tobacco:The Senate passed legislation earlier today that would place Tobacco under the control of the FDA. See how your Congressman or Senator voted. Also, be sure to read this great article on the problems this regulation will bring.

"Mr. Brown's" Brown Shirts: I have decided to write an open letter to the Democrat members of Congress. And I'm sharing it with you, dear reader, since it helps illustrate anew why Mark Twain called Congress "America's only truly criminal class."

Be sure to follow us on Twitter!

600,000 New Stimulus Jobs?: Uh, sure, just like Christine Romer predicted that Porkulus would prevent unemployment from hitting a stratospheric 8.8%. And, of course, it did — it's now up to 9.4% and rising and we have $800 billion more debt on our hands. Never mind the earlier missed predictions, Barack Obama says, and get ready for Stimu-Jobs!

$100 Billion IMF Expansion: On June 6th, the International Monetary Fund's First Deputy Managing Director John Lipsky dropped a bombshell on the dollar. He said, "The largest debtor is very unlikely to dominate any currency arrangement today" referring to the serious decline of U.S. status on account of the nation's astronomical $11.3 trillion debt.

If you haven't been following the coming FDA Tobacco ban, check these stories out:

First they Came for Tobacco: In typical fashion, the political elite on Capitol Hill seem less interested in weighing the pros and cons of important issues than wielding the scepter of power at impotent opponents.

Equal Justice or Hypocrisy as Usual: The go-to conscience of Congress, Tom Coburn (R-OK), has once again stepped on the toes of the politics-as-usual crowd by revealing the hypocrisy-as-usual that has come to define the Washington elite. And he did it by proposing an amendment he knew was dead-on-arrival.

Hypocrisy as Usual: The government has no place in regulating tobacco. Yet, 13 Senators seem to be ok with this newest of regulations while voting No on Coburn's amendment which would have placed marijuana under the same regulations. A vote no on regulating marijuana should also be a vote no on the bill on the Senate floor. Coburn's test worked, these 13 hypocrites have been exposed.

In case you missed it! Check out this cartoon from William Warren on Obama's Nuclear Energy double standard.

Be sure to follow us on Twitter!